Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

BEST SELLERS

BEST SELLERS

A collection of our most popular cake toppers

BEST SELLERS

Your cart

Loading...

Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
Pinterest

SHOP OUR SPRING COLLECTION

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER AND RECEIVE 20% OFF YOUR FIRST ORDER!

HANDCRAFTED CAKE TOPPERS FOR ALL OCCASIONS

HOME
ABOUT US
FAQ
CONTACT
NEW ARRIVALS
SHOP ALL
- BIRTHDAY
  
  MERMAID
  FARM
  RAINBOW
  UNICORN
  DINOSAUR
  NUMBER
  BOY BIRTHDAY
  1ST BIRTHDAY
  GIRL BIRTHDAY
- BABY SHOWER
  
  WOODLAND BABY
  BEARS
  GENDER NEUTRAL
- FALL
- KEEPSAKE ORNAMENTS
- PRINTED TOPPERS
  
  BOY BIRTHDAY
  GIRL BIRTHDAY
  BOY BABY SHOWER
  GIRL BABY SHOWER
  BABY'S 1ST
- DIY PRINTABLE TOPPERS
DIY PRINTABLE TOPPERS

Country/region

Search

Facebook
Pinterest
Instagram
YouTube

Search

HOME
ABOUT US
FAQ
CONTACT
NEW ARRIVALS
SHOP ALL
PERSONALIZED FOR BABY

SUMMER BIRTHDAYS
DIY PRINTABLE TOPPERS

Country/region

Search

Search

Collection: Products

Filter:

Availability

0 selected

Availability

In stock (117 products)
Out of stock (23 products)

Price

The highest price is $110.00

$

From

$

To

Product type

0 selected

Product type

Baby Shower (4 products)
baby shower (2 products)
baby shower cake topper (12 products)
Birthday Party (31 products)
cake topper (45 products)
Cake topper (18 products)
Christmas ornament (4 products)
party supplies (1 product)

More filters

0 selected

More filters

1st birthday cake topper (25 products)
1st birthday party decor (24 products)
animals with flower crowns (4 products)
baby boy (8 products)
baby boy's 1st birthday (10 products)
baby girl (7 products)
baby girl cake topper (12 products)
baby girl cake toppergirl baby shower (5 products)
baby girl shower (10 products)
baby girl's 1st birthday (10 products)
baby girl's birthday (12 products)
baby shower cake topper (42 products)
baby turns 1 (11 products)
baby turns one (6 products)
baby's 1st birthday (49 products)
beach birthday (5 products)
beach party (4 products)
beach party decor (19 products)
birthday cake topper (5 products)
boho baby shower (21 products)
boy 1st birthday (8 products)
boy baby shower (5 products)
boy's birthday (14 products)
boy's birthday cake decoration (8 products)
cake topper (36 products)
cake topper for baby girl (11 products)
cake topper for girls birthday (16 products)
caticorn (4 products)
caticorn birthday (4 products)
caticorn cake topper (4 products)
child's birthday decor (7 products)
custom cake topper (9 products)
custom rainbow cake decoration (4 products)
cute deer cake topper (4 products)
deer cake topper (8 products)
expecting partents (6 products)
fall birthday (5 products)
fox cake topper (11 products)
gender neutral baby shower (9 products)
gender neutral baby shower decor (16 products)
gender neutral cake topper (12 products)
girl's birthday (8 products)
girl's birthday decoration (10 products)
girls birthday (28 products)
girls summer birthday (5 products)
happy birthday cake topper (9 products)
It's a boy (17 products)
it's a girl (10 products)
its a girl (10 products)
jellycakesshoppe (10 products)
keepsake cake topper (14 products)
mermaid cake decor (11 products)
mermaid cake topper (11 products)
new baby girl (5 products)
non edible cake decor (29 products)
non edible cake topper (16 products)
non edible unicorn cake topper (6 products)
nonedible (6 products)
nonedible cake decor (13 products)
nonedible cake decoration (16 products)
nonedible cake topper (13 products)
paper cake topper (19 products)
pastel mermaid cake decorration (6 products)
pastel rainbow cake topper (6 products)
pastel rainbow unicorn (14 products)
personalized cake topper (5 products)
personalized mermaid cake topper (11 products)
polymer clay cake topper (55 products)
polymer clay unicorn (5 products)
rainbow and clouds cake topper (6 products)
rainbow birthday (7 products)
rainbow birthday decor (8 products)
rainbow cake decoration (8 products)
rainbow cake decorations (5 products)
rainbow cake topper (20 products)
rainbow unicorn cake topper (12 products)
summer birthday ideas (20 products)
under the sea birthday decor (15 products)
under the sea cake topper (11 products)
unicorn birthday (8 products)
unicorn birthday party (15 products)
unicorn cake decor (15 products)
unicorn cake decorations (8 products)
unicorn cake topper (17 products)
unicorn with banner (5 products)
welcome baby (12 products)
woodland animal cake topper (13 products)
woodland animals cake decor (14 products)
woodland animals cake topper (7 products)
woodland baby shower (29 products)
woodland baby shower cake topper (14 products)
woodland birthday (8 products)
woodland birthday cake topper (11 products)
woodland birthday decor (16 products)
woodland cake decor (19 products)
woodland cake topper for boy (5 products)
woodland centerpiece (11 products)
woodland deer cake topper (10 products)
woodland fox cake topper (12 products)
woodland table decor (18 products)

Age

0 selected

Age

1 (33 products)
2 (33 products)
3 (33 products)
4 (33 products)
5 (31 products)
6 (30 products)
7 (30 products)
8 (29 products)
9 (25 products)
10 (25 products)
11 (5 products)
12 (4 products)
89 (1 product)
CUSTOM (3 products)
CUSTOM AGE (2 products)
no age (7 products)
NO AGE (4 products)
NO AGE/NAME INSTEAD (1 product)

Banner Personalization

0 selected

Banner Personalization

BABY'S 1ST (12 products)
BABY'S 1ST BIRTHDAY (12 products)
HAPPY BIRTHDAY (13 products)
HAPPY BIRTHDAY + NAME (1 product)
IT'S A BOY (4 products)
IT'S A GIRL (8 products)
LET'S BE MERMAIDS (1 product)
NAME (13 products)
NAME + 1ST BIRTHDAY (12 products)
NEW BABY (12 products)
WELCOME BABY (12 products)

Color

0 selected

Color

Sort by:

117 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

117 products

Availability

In stock (117 products)
Out of stock (23 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $110.00

$

From

$

To

Clear

Product type

Baby Shower (4 products)
baby shower (2 products)
baby shower cake topper (12 products)
Birthday Party (31 products)
cake topper (45 products)
Cake topper (18 products)
Christmas ornament (4 products)
party supplies (1 products)

Clear

More filters

1st birthday cake topper (25 products)
1st birthday party decor (24 products)
animals with flower crowns (4 products)
baby boy (8 products)
baby boy's 1st birthday (10 products)
baby girl (7 products)
baby girl cake topper (12 products)
baby girl cake toppergirl baby shower (5 products)
baby girl shower (10 products)
baby girl's 1st birthday (10 products)
baby girl's birthday (12 products)
baby shower cake topper (42 products)
baby turns 1 (11 products)
baby turns one (6 products)
baby's 1st birthday (49 products)
beach birthday (5 products)
beach party (4 products)
beach party decor (19 products)
birthday cake topper (5 products)
boho baby shower (21 products)
boy 1st birthday (8 products)
boy baby shower (5 products)
boy's birthday (14 products)
boy's birthday cake decoration (8 products)
cake topper (36 products)
cake topper for baby girl (11 products)
cake topper for girls birthday (16 products)
caticorn (4 products)
caticorn birthday (4 products)
caticorn cake topper (4 products)
child's birthday decor (7 products)
custom cake topper (9 products)
custom rainbow cake decoration (4 products)
cute deer cake topper (4 products)
deer cake topper (8 products)
expecting partents (6 products)
fall birthday (5 products)
fox cake topper (11 products)
gender neutral baby shower (9 products)
gender neutral baby shower decor (16 products)
gender neutral cake topper (12 products)
girl's birthday (8 products)
girl's birthday decoration (10 products)
girls birthday (28 products)
girls summer birthday (5 products)
happy birthday cake topper (9 products)
It's a boy (17 products)
it's a girl (10 products)
its a girl (10 products)
jellycakesshoppe (10 products)
keepsake cake topper (14 products)
mermaid cake decor (11 products)
mermaid cake topper (11 products)
new baby girl (5 products)
non edible cake decor (29 products)
non edible cake topper (16 products)
non edible unicorn cake topper (6 products)
nonedible (6 products)
nonedible cake decor (13 products)
nonedible cake decoration (16 products)
nonedible cake topper (13 products)
paper cake topper (19 products)
pastel mermaid cake decorration (6 products)
pastel rainbow cake topper (6 products)
pastel rainbow unicorn (14 products)
personalized cake topper (5 products)
personalized mermaid cake topper (11 products)
polymer clay cake topper (55 products)
polymer clay unicorn (5 products)
rainbow and clouds cake topper (6 products)
rainbow birthday (7 products)
rainbow birthday decor (8 products)
rainbow cake decoration (8 products)
rainbow cake decorations (5 products)
rainbow cake topper (20 products)
rainbow unicorn cake topper (12 products)
summer birthday ideas (20 products)
under the sea birthday decor (15 products)
under the sea cake topper (11 products)
unicorn birthday (8 products)
unicorn birthday party (15 products)
unicorn cake decor (15 products)
unicorn cake decorations (8 products)
unicorn cake topper (17 products)
unicorn with banner (5 products)
welcome baby (12 products)
woodland animal cake topper (13 products)
woodland animals cake decor (14 products)
woodland animals cake topper (7 products)
woodland baby shower (29 products)
woodland baby shower cake topper (14 products)
woodland birthday (8 products)
woodland birthday cake topper (11 products)
woodland birthday decor (16 products)
woodland cake decor (19 products)
woodland cake topper for boy (5 products)
woodland centerpiece (11 products)
woodland deer cake topper (10 products)
woodland fox cake topper (12 products)
woodland table decor (18 products)

Clear

Age

1 (33 products)
2 (33 products)
3 (33 products)
4 (33 products)
5 (31 products)
6 (30 products)
7 (30 products)
8 (29 products)
9 (25 products)
10 (25 products)
11 (5 products)
12 (4 products)
89 (1 products)
CUSTOM (3 products)
CUSTOM AGE (2 products)
no age (7 products)
NO AGE (4 products)
NO AGE/NAME INSTEAD (1 products)

Clear

Banner Personalization

BABY'S 1ST (12 products)
BABY'S 1ST BIRTHDAY (12 products)
HAPPY BIRTHDAY (13 products)
HAPPY BIRTHDAY + NAME (1 products)
IT'S A BOY (4 products)
IT'S A GIRL (8 products)
LET'S BE MERMAIDS (1 products)
NAME (13 products)
NAME + 1ST BIRTHDAY (12 products)
NEW BABY (12 products)
WELCOME BABY (12 products)

Clear

Color

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

117 products

Pastel Mermaid Cake Decorations

Pastel Mermaid Cake Decorations

Regular price From $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $12.00 USD
Unit price per
Pastel Mermaid Cake Topper

Pastel Mermaid Cake Topper

Regular price From $12.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $12.00 USD
Unit price per
Pastel Rainbow Cake Topper

Pastel Rainbow Cake Topper

Regular price $24.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 USD
Unit price per
Pastel Rainbow Mermaid Cake Topper

Pastel Rainbow Mermaid Cake Topper

Regular price From $28.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $28.00 USD
Unit price per
Pastel Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake Decorations

Pastel Rainbow Unicorn Birthday Cake Decorations

Regular price From $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $18.00 USD
Unit price per
Pastel Rainbow Unicorn Cake Topper

Pastel Rainbow Unicorn Cake Topper

Regular price From $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $18.00 USD
Unit price per
Pastel Rainbow Unicorn Cake Topper

Pastel Rainbow Unicorn Cake Topper

Regular price $32.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $32.00 USD
Unit price per
Pegasus Cake Topper

Pegasus Cake Topper

Regular price From $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $16.00 USD
Unit price per
Penguin Birthday Cake Topper

Penguin Birthday Cake Topper

Regular price From $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $18.00 USD
Unit price per
Penguin Birthday Cake Topper for Girl

Penguin Birthday Cake Topper for Girl

Regular price From $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $18.00 USD
Unit price per
Personalized Gingerbread Family Christmas Ornament

Personalized Gingerbread Family Christmas Ornament

Regular price From $34.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $34.00 USD
Unit price per
Personalized Rainbow Unicorn Cake Topper

Personalized Rainbow Unicorn Cake Topper

Regular price From $14.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $14.00 USD
Unit price per

1
2
3
4
5
6
…
10

FOLLOW ON INSTAGRAM

QUICK LINKS

Search
Refunds
Terms of Service
Shipping

WHO WE ARE

Jelly Cakes is a small party brand which is run from our cozy New England studio where we design and handcraft cute cake toppers, party accessories, and gifts with love xo

Join the CAKE TOPPER CLUB to receive 20% off your 1st order and be the first to know about new collections and special offers!

Email

Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
Pinterest

Copyright © 2026 jellycakesshoppe - All Rights Reserved - Site Design

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Shipping policy
Contact information

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.